St. Elizabeth School of Nursing logo
Search
Close this search box.

Ethical Dilemmas

Nurse holding hands with patient

Share Post:

People often choose a career in nursing because they are called to care for others. Part of patient care is making treatment decisions with health and comfort in mind. When choices need to be made, ethics can come into play. Seeking resolution when options are less than ideal can prove even more difficult. Understanding the role ethics and decision-making play is critical to a nurse’s mission.

Code of Ethics for Nurses

In 1950, the American Nurses Association (ANA) adopted its first Code of Ethics. Over the years, it has been revisited and revised due to changes in laws and advances in research and technology. The code is based on seven underlying principles: beneficence, nonmaleficence, justice, accountability, autonomy, fidelity and integrity. The code itself includes points such as human dignity, relationships with colleagues, conflict of interest, collaboration, delegation of tasks and duties to self.

According to the ANA, the code in today’s environment is paramount. It reiterates fundamental values and commitments nurses pledge to adhere to, clearly states boundaries within duty and loyalty and goes beyond patient encounters when defining the nurse’s role. Nurse managers make tough decisions every day. Their staff and patients look to them to ensure health and safety standards while caring for the well-being of all on their floor.

Ethically Challenging Situations

Nursing is a fast-paced job that has its unique challenges. Nurses will encounter tough situations no matter how long they have been practicing. Ensuring staff understands expectations in difficult circumstances can keep small issues from becoming big problems. Yet when they arise—and they will—learning what to do and what not to do, is the best on-the-job training a nurse can receive.

Some examples of ethically challenging situations include:

1 – Science and spirituality

Healthcare is science-based. Some religions have strict principles in place concerning medical intervention. For patients and their families with strong convictions, it can be challenging for a nurse with different values or moral codes. Respecting a patient’s stance does not mean it is condoned. Instead, it is adhering to the care a patient has requested.

2 – Needs and resources

Healthcare costs are rising. Budget constraints may seem to conflict with patient needs. Resources and staffing are a problem at many facilities. These factors contradict the patient care protocols healthcare workers have sworn to uphold. Nurses must come to terms with the truth: they are doing their very best with what they’ve been tasked with, including allotted resources.

3 – Honesty and information

Patients’ families may ask you not to tell your patient their entire health picture. They want to protect their loved one from pain or news that’s difficult to process. Patients have the right to know their diagnosis and medical outlook. Deciding how to share complex information can be tricky, but telling the truth is the basis of the nurse-patient relationship. Without that in place, patients will develop a lack of trust in the medical staff. That barrier can impede wellness and healing.

4 – Autonomy and care

Patients may not want to take medication a nurse tries to administer. Some may put on their clothes and walk out of the hospital before receiving proper treatment. Others may ask for a different nurse for unknown reasons. A patient maintaining their autonomy—sole decision-making power—means they have the right to refuse care despite apparent needs. Understanding a patient’s background, history and any previous issues with healthcare providers can allow nurses to find solutions based on respect, honesty, openness and care tailored to the individual while delivering the message of medical necessity.

5 – Recognizing incompetence in care

Peers can struggle with whether they should simply guide their fellow nurses, handle treatment for them or report the issue to a superior. For those in positions of authority, these issues can be addressed before they become problems by refreshing staff about the Code of Ethics. Scheduling regular training and checking on newer nurses to ensure they are up-to-date on procedural expectations is also essential.

Dealing with ethical issues is something that goes beyond textbook and clinical preparation. They are complex situations nurses gain skills from and confidence to deal with over time. Empathy and boundaries can coexist in patient care. Being surrounded by experienced coworkers can provide guidance and a shoulder to lean on. Open dialogue can also help nurses learn from the mistakes of others and better equip themselves when challenges arise.

As seen in the The Lamp fall 2023 issue

More from The Lamp

Finding Balance

Wherever we are in our journey, achieving a harmonious balance between our professional and personal lives is an ongoing challenge. For nurses and other healthcare professionals, this balance is...

The Heartwarming Legacy of Susie Castor

We are honored to spotlight Mike Castor and the scholarship he established in memory of his beloved wife, Susie Castor, affectionately known to him as “Suze.” Their story is...

A Legacy of Care

We are excited to highlight a remarkable family of nurses whose journey is intertwined with the history and spirit of St. Elizabeth School of Nursing. Meet Laci Frodge and...

Growing Our Own: Nurturing Talent from Within

At St. Elizabeth School of Nursing, the philosophy of “growing our own" is not just a mantra; it’s a deeply ingrained practice. By focusing on hiring, promoting and developing...

From Grounds to Garden

We are excited to share the latest updates on the ongoing St. Elizabeth Garden project, a green space initiative that continues to transform our campus. This garden is being...

The Healing Power of Green Spaces

In the demanding world of nursing, where the balance between compassionate caregiving and personal wellbeing is often precarious, maintaining balanced mental health can quickly slide out of control. We...

Class of 2025 Indiana AHEC Scholars Program

The Indiana AHEC Scholars program is part of a national initiative designed for individuals who possess a strong drive to provide care to those living in rural and medically...

Remembering Our Time at St. Elizabeth

Watch this video to hear Alumni Coral Smith, Toni Bluemke, Mary Vandervolgen-Goldman and Sharron Parker reminisce about the old St. Elizabeth School of Nursing building. We need your help...